OutsidetheGarden.com - The Fish Bowl - The Neo-Optimist
  IN THE FORUMS >> VIEWS REPLIES  
  ■  Eastern Conference Semifina... 128 14  
  ■  NHL Playoff Predictions 804 44  
  ■  ECQF Game 6: Montreal Canad... 2072 446  
  ■  AV sucks 3909 286  
  ■  Henrik out 2-3 weeks 634 12  
RANGERS CAP NUMBER
$74,115,201
HOME PAGE
PUCK PICKS 2012
CONTACT US
FORUMS
TEAM
ROSTER
SCHEDULE
DEPTH CHART
INJURIES
CONTRACTS
CAP STATUS
PROSPECTS
STAFF
STATISTICS
PROSPECT STATS
STANDINGS
TRANSACTIONS
DRAFT
ENTRY DRAFT
DRAFT PICKS
DRAFT HISTORY
PRESEASON
PROSPECT CAMP
TRAINING CAMP
TRAVERSE CITY
STATISTICS
NEWS & INFO
HEADLINES
LINKS
RUMOR MILL
THE GARDEN
CALENDAR
MULTIMEDIA
VIDEO
WALLPAPERS
OTG ON FACEBOOK
OTG ON TWITTER
MORE TWITTER
HISTORY
AFFILIATES
ALL TIME ROSTER
AWARDS
CAPTAINS
COACHES
GEN. MANAGERS
HALL OF FAME
LOGOS
STATISTICS
PRESIDENTS
RETIRED NUMBERS
SEASONS
OTG CONTENT
ARCHIVES
CLOSE ENCOUNTERS
NEXT STOP: 34th
OTG NOTEBOOK
RANGER BLUE
RANGER ROVER
RRANGER RICOCHET
THE FISH BOWL
OFFICIAL SITES
MSG
RANGERS
WOLF PACK
SWAMP RABBITS
NHL
NHLPA
REFERENCES
B'SHIRT BULLETIN
CAP GEEK
HOCKEY DB
HOCKEY'S FUTURE
HOCKEY RODENT
HOWLINGS
KUKLA'S KORNER
NHL NUMBERS
NY SPORTS DAY
SPECTOR'S H'KEY

New York Rangers Fan Club

by Toby Ivey

The Neo-Optimist
February 13, 2005

I am a born again optimist...a neo-optimist if you will.  I am confident for the first time in months, that there will indeed be an NHL season AND a corresponding CBA in place in a matter of days.  Okay so you might think I cracked under the weight of the prospect that the season will finally be cancelled next week, and that there is no basis whatsoever for my optimism.  Perhaps you're right, but after some careful consideration I think I might be on to something and I would like to share my reason why here in this column.

First off left me state categorically, that no, I do not have any insider information and am simply basing this opinion on my own reasoning conducted early Saturday morning.

The beginning of the process begins with the public acknowledgement by NHL Commissioner Garry Bettman that the season would probably not be viable if a draft of a proposed CBA was not being worked on this weekend.  In other words he was finally announcing the much anticipated "drop dead date". It should be noted that both at the time, and during follow up questioning was he willing to commit to an actual date so there appears to be at least some wiggle room left...but the important thing for me was that he was talking about the cancellation of the season in terms of an impending  reality rather than something to be considered at some later date.  Bill Daly later confirmed the position by stating that it was just a matter of when, not if...though I'll get into this type of comment later.

The other important step this past week, was the softening of the league's stance on the linkage issue (the tie between revenues and payrolls set arbitrarily at 53-55%).  Linkage had long been a key issue with the NHLPA and was compounded by the probability of reduced revenues following the lockout that could have seen the NHL's proposed salary cap range drop by as much as 20-30% in it's first year of implementation.  The comment by Bill Daly on Saturday offered the opening on which the NHLPA can offer an updated proposal and a point from which they can finally negotiate.

Having taken into account these two important developments, I then went back and tried to understand (or perhaps rationalize) the process up to this point to see whether I could support my sudden optimism.

The first important point to consider is that the two main protagonists both come from a labor relations background.  Gary Bettman studied labor relations at Cornell and went on to work in the NBA under David Stern before moving over to the NHL.  He was involved in the 1994-95 CBA process, as well as the negotiations between the league and the officials in the late 90s.  His opponent in these negotiations also has a string of credits to his name.  As with Bettman, Goodenow is a graduate from an Ivy League School and has a background in law and labor relations.  Goodenow's experience extends beyond that of the sporting world into other businesses, but he is equally if not more qualified for his position.  Both men know how to work the media, time announcements and engineer leaks to their advantage in the great negotiating game.

Also to be taken into consideration, is the art of negotiation in and of itself.  You can in some ways draw an analogy with playing poker and the art of bluffing.  During the process you are trying to undermine the oppositions commitment to their position as well as feeling out the possible viability of your own position.  Granted in these labor negotiations there are many aspects and points on which you can compromise, but the basic comparison I think is valid.  The purpose of the proposals to date, as well as the comments both official and unofficial have been largely directed to the opposing constituencies and to a lesser extent the general public.  The goal is to create doubt amongst the league owners and players respectively, as well as to bring public pressure to bear on those same individuals.

This process would liable to continue forever, or until one side caves if there wasn't something at stake.  The point of all this is of course the division of a large pool of money and both sides recognize that alternatives to getting a CBA deal done are far from satisfying...at least in financial terms.

While an impasse might sound like a great idea for the owners, the realities of implementing one and then attempting to run a league with replacement players is not a particularly practical or cheap option.  Arenas have overheads and there needs to be a good deal of money coming in to make it worthwhile, not to mention attract sponsorship and advertising.  The prospect of watching career AHLers and other from various pro and semi-pro leagues, combined with the lesser lights willing to cross the line is hardly a model for success.  While it might provide a degree of pressure on the union, it might take even longer for the league to get their impasse improved by the appropriate authorities both in the US and the provinces of Canada, not to mention the potential problems associated with using foreign nationals as replacements.  On the player's side, there is realistically little money to be made in Europe, where the average salary is around $150,000 a year and million dollar contracts are only available to a handful of players in a league where attendance is on par with the AHL.

By my reasoning, the cancellation of the season is the most important leveraging point of all for both sides.

Given this view of the process to date, it leads me to no other conclusion than that there is a high likelihood of a deal being done in the next few days, with an announcement maybe as soon as Tuesday.  It may very well be that we see one side or the other cave, or we could see a true compromise but whatever the outcome we will have a season.

Now feel free to return to reality and your own point of view...


E-mail the author


 Additional stories from this Author:

YOUR COMMENTS

POST COMMENT >>
DATE AUTHOR COMMENT
12/8/2015 supra sneakers
POST COMMENT >>
April 22nd, 2017
MADISON SQUARE GARDEN
  1 2 3 T
0 2 1 3
1 0 0 1
FIRST PERIOD: 1. MON Emelin (Radulov,Lehkonen) MON 1-0    SECOND PERIOD: 2. NYR Zuccarello (Zibanejad,McDonagh) Tied 1-1   3. NYR Zuccarello (Hayes,Miller) NYR 2-1    THIRD PERIOD: 4. NYR Stepan (Girardi) NYR 3-1   
Boxscore Game Thread
  NEXT GAMES
Complete Schedule
  HEADLINES
Kreider Expected Back As Ranger...
- CBS New York 11/18

Mats Zuccarello's Rangers Resur...
- New York Post 11/18

Chris Kreider returns to practi...
- New York Newsday 11/17

Blue Jackets notebook | Dubinsk...
- Columbus Dispatch 11/17

Rangers Roll, but not Without I...
- The Hockey Writers 11/17

Prospect Update: Halverson Gets...
- New York Rangers 11/17

Kreider Returns to Rangers Prac...
- New York Rangers 11/17

Rangers Assign Cristoval Nieves...
- New York Rangers 11/17

Kreider to practice with Ranger...
- New York Daily News 11/17

Rangers can finally exhale with...
- New York Post 11/17

More news...



October 14th, 2016

Who was the last #40 to score a goal for NYR before Grabner?

Answer...
  STANDINGS
  Team GP W L OT Pts  
  Capitals 82 55 19 8 118  
  Penguins 82 50 21 11 111  
  Blue Jackets 82 50 24 8 108  
  Canadiens 82 47 26 9 103  
  Rangers 82 48 28 6 102  
  Senators 82 44 28 10 98  
  Bruins 82 44 31 7 95  
  Maple Leafs 82 40 27 15 95  
  Islanders 82 41 29 12 94  
  Lightning 82 42 30 10 94  
  Flyers 82 39 33 10 88  
  Hurricanes 82 36 31 15 87  
  Panthers 82 35 36 11 81  
  Red Wings 82 33 36 13 79  
  Sabres 82 33 37 12 78  
  Devils 82 28 40 14 70  
FULL STANDINGS
  RANDOM RANGER

BILL CHALMERS
(1953-1954)
  Born: Jan 24 - 1934  
  Pos: Center  
  GP: 1  
  G: 0  
  A: 0  
  Pts: 0  
  PIMs: 0  

About Us -  Site Map  -  Contact Us


© Copyright OutsideTheGarden.com 2001-17
This site and it's content is in no way affiliated with, or representative of the 
NHL
, NHLPA or the New York Rangers