Smits Discussion
Over the last few games we are starting to see Smits making more mistakes despite his under 15min/game usage -much below the other 5 dmen. His decision making and skating are showing flaws and he seems to be getting manhandled in the d end more often.
1. Clearly fatigue has set in
2. The other teams' scouting and analytics are always looking for flaws - the other guys are pros, too
3. He has shown minimal offense
4. He is not playing on the pk
All this is understandable for an 18 year old.
The question is what are the NYR thinking about with Smits? On one hand, losing Igor means the NYR might not make the playoffs so there is no harm to the team throwing Smits out there every night. On the other hand, maybe Smits playing in Hartford 20min/night plus pk and no NHL pressure might do Smits some good and allow him to work on things, including getting his man strength.
Replacing him with Robertson might even help the NYR right now. I never understand the rush to put a guy in the NHL when he is clearly not dominant on the ice and actually being protected every night. Robertson had a decent 3rd pair season last year and has the capabilities to not make mistakes and pickup some PK time to help the other dmen.
Is staying in NY about
1. Getting him better coaching/training/physio?
2. Living arrangements for an 18 year old might be difficult in Hartford vs NY?
3. Do the NYR want to pay him the larger salary but cannot if they send him to Hartford?
IMHO he should be spending time in Hartford for a month or 2. I would love to know what the NYR are thinking.
What do you guys think?
1 Cup in 86 years
2048
I think a couple of things... I think the rest will help him. I don't think he has played a schedule like this before. I think the whole team has played poorly defensively recently and that is not just on the D Men... He is 3rd pair and playing 3rd pair minutes. At least he is not playing soft... he is hitting. His recent issues tend to be being out of position and fatigue can contribute to that and that can be coachable. Let's see what he looks like after this rest along with the rest of the team.
If they need me to bleed, then I'll bleed for my team
I agree. I sometimes think he's trying to do that little bit extra which, naturally, takes him out of position. Looked at the schedule and realized they're playing every other night with some back to backs thrown in. That's a tough grind for a veteran. I think Hartford is the best option for him right now. Unfortunately, I doubt it will happen considering Sully's lack of faith in Robertson and Morrow.Posted by: @pierre_pdareI think a couple of things... I think the rest will help him. I don't think he has played a schedule like this before. I think the whole team has played poorly defensively recently and that is not just on the D Men... He is 3rd pair and playing 3rd pair minutes. At least he is not playing soft... he is hitting. His recent issues tend to be being out of position and fatigue can contribute to that and that can be coachable. Let's see what he looks like after this rest along with the rest of the team.
I said elsewhere no shame in Smits stumbling. He's just gone through the toughest 2 months of his life and in particular in his hockey career. This week off is good timing for him. Rangers have got bigger problems than Smits on defense. Braden Schneider good enough to play into the third round of the playoffs with two different coaching staffs. Last season and so far this season with Sullivan and his boy David Quinn in charge of the defense, and he's fighting it. Now Durzi is also struggling. I always thought Pettersson was a ridiculous pickup especially at a price the Rangers will never come close to getting back. Paid a first round pick in 2030 and if a top ten pick it moves to 2031. How's that for stiffing the hopefully soon to be new G.M. Mathew Robertson can replace Petterssen with out any hiccups. Fireable trade by Drury. But at what point do you realize Quinn is the problem. K'andre Miller goes to Carolina top pair borderline All Star. Schneider's development needle hasn't moved since Sullivan and Quinn got here. Now Durzi warts and Pettersson living up to my expectations. Rangers D is in trouble if Quinn doesn't get Durzi, Pettersson, and Schneider going, all the while mentoring Smits through this season. And I will believe that when I see it.
- 8 Forums
- 803 Topics
- 25.8 K Posts
- 22 Online
- 49 Members
