AUGUST
«
Fri
28
Sat
29
Sun
30
Mon
31
Tue
1
Wed
2
Thu
3
»
Last updated 10 minutes ago

When The Sum Is Less Than The Parts

Barclay Goodrow for six years at $3.64M.  The trade of Pavel Buchneivch for only a slightly better return that what Lias Andersson drew less than a year ago – and a report that said the Rangers were willing to walk away from him for nothing.  The acquisition of Ryan Reaves for a third round pick, and his ensuing extension for another year.  A draft that was noticeable for it’s heavy focus on physical players over skill.  The signing of two players – Reaves and defenseman Jarred Tinordi, known for their willingness to throw down, particularly with a specific person of interest.

Each one of these things could pass on it’s own, but taken as a whole raises a question: just how obsessed with Tom Wilson have the Rangers become?

The same Tom Wilson who caused Glen Sather to emerge from the shadows.  The same Tom Wilson who drew owner Jim Dolan to excoriate George Parros and the NHL Department of Player Safety publicly, and earn a record setting $250,000 fine.  The same Tom Wilson who played two nights later following the surprise firings of President John Davidson and GM Jeff Gorton hours before.

Deny it all you want, but it seems pretty compelling now that Jim Dolan did fire the Rangers leadership because of THAT incident despite claims to the contrary.  It also seems clear that Drury was given the instructins to make sure something like it didn’t happen again.

What’s less clear is how much of this is Sather’s doing and how much is Jim Dolan’s wounded pride.  Clearly Sather has some role in this, given his re-emergence after three years of relative obscurity.  Whether Sather instigated the coup, or whether it was solely Dolan’s emotional reaction, is hard to ascertain, but we are now enjoying the repercussions.

This obsessive focus on making the Rangers “tougher” seems close to going off the rails at this stage.  

There have been a number of analyses that show players typically hit their prime around 28 years of age, which conveniently aligns to around the time they first become UFAs.  It’s not surprising then than greater than 80% of UFA contracts turn out to be bad investments, moreso for physical role-players who generally deteriorate quickly.

Acquiring a 34 year old enforcer in a league where there are few who play the role, also carries some risk.  At the very least he just takes up cap space, at worst he also blocks ice time for thel likes of Morgan Barron who perhaps have more to offer in their game.  Extending him another year while he’s under contract, and is yet to play a game for the franchise just makes it worse.

When that enforcer, and the 7th defenseman you signed are both known for fighting Tom Wilson in particular, it really does make you wonder.

It’s not like the Capitals won the Cup this year.

So why Chris?  Why are you so focused on Tom Wilson when the team that did win the Cup two seasons in a row is what you should be aspiring to.

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
September 21, 2026
Preseason Matchup Preview
NYR
NYR
VS
7:00 PM
Prudential Center
NJD
NJD

LATEST FORUM POSTS

View All →
By 4 days ago
  Hahaha thanks for the daystarter lmao. Always need one of them.    
By 5 days ago
I think their front office is #2. A giant steaming pile of it.
By 6 days ago
Certainly would be interesting if they can pull that off, and probably also relies on Shesterkin and Fox staying healthier than they have (and Zibanejad remaining healthy).  But it...
By 6 days ago
What Could Happen If a Lot of Things Go Right Let's establish something up front: this isn't a prediction that the Rangers will definitely finish with 99 points. It's an optimistic...
By 6 days ago
But I can see (hope to see) improvements in Laf, Laba and Perrault and some better 3 and 4 line play from Chmelar, Kartye. I want to see a better skating grittier team. And if not,...
Metropolitan
TeamGPWLOTPts
zCAR8253227113
xPHI8243271298
xPIT8241251698
eWSH824330995
eCBJ8240301292
eNYI824334591
eNJD824237387
eNYR823439977
Active Injuries
Player Status Injury
Matt Rempe LTIR Hand
ON THIS DAY: AUGUST 31
No games played on this day.
Birthdays
Fern GauthierBorn 1919
Bryce LampmanBorn 1982
Blake WheelerBorn 1986
Transactions
1995 - Petr Nedved: Traded
1995 - Wayne Presley: Signed
1995 - Luc Robitaille: Acquired
1995 - Ulf Samuelsson: Acquired
1995 - Sergei Zubov: Traded
[box]
TOP
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x